European Commission
EuroTB
Surveillance of tuberculosis
World Health Organization
[ menu ] [ previous page ]  

3. Data collection

Among the 51 countries of the WHO European Region, all but one (Turkey) sent data on tuberculosis cases notified in 1996:

  • 47 countries reported all new and recurrent cases;
  • 2 countries (Greece and Kazakstan) reported only new cases;
  • 1 country (Spain) reported only new respiratory cases.

Complementary information on the characteristics of the national surveillance systems according to the European recommendations (case definition, population groups systematically excluded from the notification, definitions of recurrent cases included in the notification, of bacteriological confirmation and of smear positivity) was provided by 46 countries. There were some differences in the definition of recurrent cases included in the notification (Table 1) :

  • 20 countries reported only the relapses, as defined by WHO [8] (cases in patients with a previous episode of tuberculosis who completed a full treatment with anti-tuberculosis drugs and were declared cured);
  • 15 countries reported relapses and other patients previously treated with anti-tuberculosis drugs, such as patients returning after interruption of treatment or patients with a previous episode of tuberculosis failing to respond to anti- tuberculosis treatment;
  • 7 countries reported cases in patients with a previous episode of tuberculosis who were not treated with anti-tuberculosis drugs (because anti-tuberculosis drugs were not available at that time) in addition to the cases mentioned above;
  • 2 countries (Bosnia-Herzegovina, United Kingdom) used different definitions of recurrent cases in different parts of the country.

However, few countries specified how these definitions were applied. Moreover, information on previous history of tuberculosis is difficult to obtain and differences in inclusion of recurrent cases may also result from differences in the procedure used to retrieve previous information.Population groups included in the notification also differed  (Table 2) :

  • 8 countries included only nationals, excluding all categories of foreigners;
  • 13 countries included nationals and legal immigrants, but excluded illegal immigrants and/or asylum seekers;
  • 12 countries excluded prisoners.

This information concerned systematic exclusion from the notification and not underreporting, which may also exist in the groups included in the notification. Among the 50 countries reporting tuberculosis cases notified in 1996, 19 provided individual computerised data, 31 provided aggregate data. The availability of information varied between countries (Box 4).

Seven countries (Belarus, Greece, Kazakstan, Kyrgyzstan, Russian Federation, Tajikistan and Ukraine) provided information on the characteristics the new cases only. In order to present all the distributions on the total number of cases (new and recurrent), results for these countries are not included in the tables or country profiles presented further in this report.


[ menu ] [ previous page ]